Friday, July 15, 2011

My patronus is a goat

A friend wrote a few days ago that not blogging about the Harry Potter movie final installment would be "a huge generational betrayal." She may be right. So just to cover my generational bases . . .

After walking out of the theater this morning (at 2:30 AM) I couldn't help but feel like it was my grade (maybe plus or minus one grade) that truly grew up with Harry. I remember reading the first book in the 5th grade. Harry and I were the same age (as are, coincidentally, Daniel Radcliffe and I). The heroes and heroines of the books grew up with me, almost at the same rate.

Near the end of the film during moments of quiet, sniffles (and sobs) could be heard echoing in the theater. But I don't think the tears were for the dead in the movie or the touching exchanges. Rather, they were tears shed for a closing of a door, for the coming of age of millions worldwide.

But I wasn't sad. For me, the sadness came when I finished reading the books. I think there is a key distinction between the book-era Potter fans and the movie-era Potter fans.

The true HP-ers, the ones that grew up with Harry, the ones that graduated from High School as Harry left Hogwarts, we had our sobbing-on-the-floor moments when we finished the books. I remember staring at the ceiling after closing the back cover and thinking, "Harry is done. And I'm going to college in two months. Childhood is officially ending." The movies are fun, yes, but I attach no nostalgia to them.

For the book-era Potter fans, we learned from Harry that geeks were cool. The coolest girl at Hogwarts was Hermione. The bad-a kids were lame and ugly. Gryffindor--where all the brainiacs go--was where you wished to be if you could somehow get in to Hogwarts.  The Harry Potter Series not only increased world-wide literacy, but it made reading hip. When else did millions of kids camp out for a book release? We devoured them.

So while it may be sad that we can't dress up and wait for the latest and greatest from the Wizarding World, I'm not sad that the movies are over. I'm sad that I don't have more time to read.

8 comments:

megan said...

So true! I love this post. I never truly got into the films as I did the books.

Morgan and Holly said...

Paige! I'm with you on that! I remember when I finished the 7th book, I couldn't believe it was actually over. I thought, "now what?" I was a little angry that there would be no more HP.

Jen & Tim said...

Oh I love this post. It seriously was SUCH a sad day when I finished the 7th HP. I agree there is such a difference from those who thrive off the books versus the movies. It was really one of those things you never thought could end, but when it did, it was a whole new world created we all got to be a apart of for years! Love this!

Anderson's said...

so true! I LOVE the books. I only saw the frist movie and last movie only because we got to see special screenings for both, the books are so good i didn't care to see the movies. we got to see it last night at 5:30, it was great! but, i love the books way more and i can't wait to start reading them with andi,

Merrick said...

Great post! I feel the same way about the books (and had my moment of sobbing on the floor when I finished the last book), but also feel like the movies really made it seem like the end. Cause now there is really no Harry Potter left to anticipate.

amanda said...

So this just popped up in my google reader recommendations, so I don't know you. BUT I totally agree about the hp-movie fans and hp-books fans. I feel exactly the same as you, that when I graduated the same time as Harry, that is when it was really over.

gigi said...

Not to sound like Hermione or anything...but the the brainiacs went to Ravenclaw.
Interesting post. I was undeniably a book-era Potter fan, but I still loved the movies and I still felt nostalgic last night, both for the books and the movies, as I watched them come to a close. All the loose ends are tied up now.

Kelsey said...

I may or may not have tears welling up in my eyes. hahahaha

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...